All blocks

Block · Stars

Sister's Choice

A star on a 5 × 5 grid: four points of half-square triangles round a cross through the middle of the block.

Other names
Sisters' Choice · Four X Star · 4X Star
Known from
USA; the name from about 1890
First known print
As no. 257, "Sister's Choice", in the catalogue of the mail-order firm Ladies' Art Company in St. Louis; the museum at Michigan State University reckons it first appeared in the 1895 catalogue. Marie Webster has the name in her list of quilt names of 1915.
Origin
Unknown, as for most traditional blocks
Brackman no.
1802c
Family
Stars
Difficulty
Medium · Triangles, geese and other angles cut with a ruler
Grid
5 × 5 cells

History

Which sister chose what? Nobody knows. Barbara Brackman writes that the Ladies' Art Company gave the block its name about 1890, and the firm's catalogue had it as no. 257.

The same catalogue had the same grid in red, green and white as no. 163, "Four X Star". In Brackman's BlockBase the block has three numbers, 1802a, 1802b and 1802c, by how it is coloured; the version with a cross in a third fabric is 1802c.

A quilt from 1901–1929 in Wisconsin is recorded under both names, "4X Star" and "Sister's Choice". Carrie A. Hall made a block in the early 1900s; it belongs to the Spencer Museum of Art in Kansas today.

How it is used

The block is built on a 5 × 5 grid of squares and eight half-square triangles. It is sewn row by row, five rows of five.

Three fabrics are enough: background, star and cross. The pattern is also called Four X Star.

Sources

The text is our own, written from the sources below. Photos of old quilts with the block are in the museums' collections.

  1. Archive Ladies' Art Company, MSU Museum / Quilt Index: LAC No. 257, Sister's Choice (1895)
  2. Archive Ladies' Art Company, MSU Museum / Quilt Index: LAC No. 163, Four X Star (1895)
  3. Article Barbara Brackman: Block 2: Sister's Choice for Cassandra E. Austen (2014)
  4. Article Barbara Brackman: My Fabric in Quilts I Didn't Make (yet) (2014)
  5. Article Barbara Brackman: Austen Family Album (2014)
  6. Book Marie D. Webster: Quilts: Their Story and How to Make Them (1915)
  7. Museum Spencer Museum of Art: Sister's Choice quilt block, Carrie A. Hall, early 1900s
  8. Archive Wisconsin Quilt History Project / Quilt Index: 4X Star, Sister's Choice, Zoe Johnson Roth, 1901–1929
  9. Article Linda Lowe: Sister's Choice (1980)
All sources and thanks